Mistaken Identity

It’s a pandemic of poseur, Pocahontas Pretendians.  America has had a recent deluge of government functionaries at all levels, falsely claiming to have Native Heritage.  It happened again!  Two more Canadian female Federal politicians, one of them the Assistant Minister of Indigenous Affairs, have been found to be pretending to have Native blood.

This goes back as far as around 1900, when an English writer came to Canada, became a trapper, called himself Grey Owl, and lived with two different Indian women to get experience and information to write a book about ‘Being An Indian.’

In the 1970s, an Italian-American styled himself as an Indian named Iron-Eyes Cody.  The government even paid him to be in an ecological TV advertisement about keeping the highways clean by not throwing trash out of cars.

While there was money to be made, these two were unusual.  Until about fifty years ago, it was considered quite déclassé for a white person to be deemed even partly indigenous, any more than being thought to be even partly Negro.

Slowly that changed.  Twenty years ago, Eileen Edwards, a white chick from Windsor, called herself Shania Twain, in celebration of her non-existent Native Heritage.  Ten years ago, Justin Bieber claimed that he was enough Indian to get free gasoline, when even full-blooded natives had to pay.

It’s become a cottage industry.  Scarcely a week goes by without another claimant being exposed.  It’s hardly an official diagnosis, but I have been told that it is a form of Indigenous Munchausen’s.  People who are nothing and nobody as a white person, claim Native background and receive sympathy as a member of an oppressed minority.  They get undeserved respect, more than their fifteen minutes of fame, and often, impressive and well-paying positions.

It’s often unclear whether these people are intentionally lying, or whether they actually believe their delusions.  A little from Column A (Or here in Canada, Column Eh.), a little from Column B.

14 thoughts on “Mistaken Identity

  1. Newbloggycat says:

    Omg, Shania Twain??? Why lie about having Indian blood? 🧐 My 10-year old daughter still denies she’s half Indian.She thinks she’s Chinese. 😝😅


  2. Rivergirl says:

    It’s quite disturbing seeing how we still treat indigenous people. Maybe we should make these fakers live in abject poverty on a reservation for a year. I think they’d change their mind.


  3. G. J. Jolly says:

    Clambering onto the bandwagon of being Native American probably gives them a feeling of having a right to be on this side of the world. After all, the tribes have been here the longest. I am one eighth Dakota. Big deal, right? I hold it dear because I admire the philosophy of these ancient people. However, I do not claim to have any claim to the land or their suffering.


  4. jim- says:

    Can I be race fluid or racially neutral? What if one is born identifying as a native? Seems where we’re headed.


  5. jim- says:

    Fake dna analysis may be even bigger than fake COVID-19 cards.


  6. “The government even paid him to be in an ecological TV advertisement about keeping the highways clean by not throwing trash out of cars.” SO that Indian with the tear in his eye when seeing the litter from our youth was Italian?!?! Huh?!?!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s